Autumn Internationals Eddie Jones England Rugby Union Rassie Erasmus Rugby Union South Africa Rugby Union Tech

Player ratings as England claw back 12-11 win at Twickenham

England v SouthAfrica Autumn Internationals line ups

Eddie Jones‘ England aspect have been jubilant as Owen Farrell’s deal with on the ultimate whistle was dominated authorized, which means that they had snatched a win over South Africa courtesy of 4 kicked penalties.

England walked out 12-11 winners however, in fact, the Springboks performed the extra fluid rugby. The guests will rue their poor recreation administration, pricey errors and determination to show down the prospect of kicking penalties which led to the upset at Twickenham.

The England pack tackled like demons and labored the breakdown exhausting within the second half, regardless of being billed because the light-weight pack, profitable the bodily battle in a cagey Check match.

Right here is how each side fared on the day.

England v SouthAfrica Autumn Internationals line ups



15. Elliot Daly – 5/10

Daly continued at full-back, together with his competitors seemingly eased by the dropping of Mike Brown (though he performed recently on the wing). An early crossfield kick misplaced to Nkosi suggests some considerations underneath the excessive ball. Shipped on a hospital cross from Farrell on his line, to Johnny Might who didn’t look completely happy. Kicked away an unlimited break for territory and England have been swiftly pressured out of the 22 within the second-half, made up for it shortly with a penalty from monumental vary. Essential in the long run. Some odd operating selections later adopted topping off a decidedly combined recreation.

14. Jack Nowell – 7/10

Confirmed tenacity in merely refusing a hand-off from de Allende, ultimately forcing a knock-on. Provided supporting runs on the break all day and put in an actual shift. Substituted off at 64 minutes. Wonderful efficiency.

England's centre Henry Slade is tackled by South Africa's flanker Duane Vermeulen (AFP/Getty Images)England’s centre Henry Slade is tackled by South Africa’s flanker Duane Vermeulen (AFP/Getty Pictures)

13. Henry Slade – 5/10

The shape outdoors centre within the Premiership retained his place from the South Africa tour. Good early grubber noticing the fast linespeed and almost put Johnny Might by means of. Additionally set the tone defensively to start with within the rush defence, however started to slide as the sport went on.

Learn extra: England vs South Africa: 5 issues we discovered as Eddie Jones’ males maintain on for victory

A stunning chip and chase within the second half on the break set the pulses racing, and it’s straightforward to see why you’d need one other distributor with a boot at 13. Six missed tackles although are an enormous concern, regardless of how good he appears going ahead.

12. Ben Te’o – eight/10

Listed as a starter regardless of enjoying solely 28 minutes since Might, indicating he’s clearly a favorite of Eddie Jones’. Ceaselessly rips ball in his monumental tackles, that are undoubtedly an enormous asset. He missed two, however the eight he made have been typically essential or possession-winning. He all the time offers with the troublesome, disagreeable jobs. Was substituted at 72 minutes for George Ford.

11. Johnny Might – eight/10

Provided in assault early, chasing grubbers and tried to defend his channel from kicks, however was pretty properly peppered. Solely grew into the sport as the sport went on, and made various robust breaks and supporting runs. Two missed tackles, admittedly, however 4 defenders crushed and an entire lot of yardage capped a superb day for the Tiger.

England co-captain Owen Farrell charged into South Africa replacement Andre Esterhuizen in the last action of the game (Getty Images)England co-captain Owen Farrell charged into South Africa alternative Andre Esterhuizen within the final motion of the sport (Getty Photographs)

10. Owen Farrell, co-captain, Saracens, 62 caps – eight/10

Learn extra: England up towards it vs South Africa? Not in accordance with bullish Owen Farrell

Beginning at 10 in his worldwide colors somewhat than 12 for as soon as, now a co-captain he additionally led out the staff. Wonderful first penalty taken from vary regardless of some distraction makes an attempt by Springbok followers within the crowd. His low level in all probability got here when he chucked a complete hospital move to Elliot Daly on his line within the first half, which was in flip shipped onto Johnny Might. Kicked his objectives fantastically and led the defensive position – a superb efficiency marred solely by two missed tackles.

9. Ben Youngs – 5/10

Labored a pleasant blindside scrum transfer with Nowell early on, put in some chaseable field kicks. Continues to sluggish play down and move with out wanting, nevertheless. Substituted off at 64 minutes for Danny Care.


1. Alec Hepburn – 6/10

Following the retirement of Joe Marler and an damage to Mako Vunipola, Hepburn acquired a beginning spot on an enormous stage. He performed properly and scrummaged arduous, and his monumental deal with rely for one half needs to be acknowledged – however he was substituted at half-time for Ben Moon to vary up the scrums.

2. Dylan Hartley – four/10

Hartley now shares captaincy duties with Owen Farrell, a system which seems designed to offer readability as to who makes selections when Jamie George ritually takes the sector 55 minutes in. Missed a simple deal with on Handré Pollard for an enormous line break, and his lineout throwing was patchy. Was within the ear of the referee for clarification quite a bit, however it will have been good to see extra effort across the park when it comes to defending – each props who began subsequent to him made extra tackles, as did the rest of the beginning pack. Was subbed off at 56 minutes.

three. Kyle Sinckler – 6/10

Conceded penalties each for scrums and offside, however didn’t do badly towards what is a gigantic Springbok tight 5. He put himself about, offloaded nicely and tackled persistently.

four. Maro Itoje – 7/10

Conceded two penalties within the first 15 minutes. Then scragged Van Zyl on the road after a crossfield kick and earned a sin bin for killing the ball within the subsequent ruck on the road. When he got here again on he was warned by the referee over constant infringements. He threw his physique into all phases of the sport making 13 tackles and lacking none, whereas additionally enjoying an enormous half in attacking phases and the breakdown.

5. George Kruis – 7/10

Equally wonderful efficiency from Kruis, who, like a lot of the English pack, persistently put his physique on the road. He additionally discovered himself breaking in assault and offloading numerous occasions. Robust efficiency.

6. Brad Shields – 6/10

Monumental deal with on de Allende in his 22 to win the ball, he settled right into a recreation doing the soiled jobs. Discovering himself on the wing within the second-half, he shipped an offload over his personal head in an try to seek out actually anybody fairly than run into contact. He as an alternative chucked it a couple of yards ahead. Baffling. This shouldn’t forged shadow on what was a really battling efficiency, whereas two defenders crushed is a pleasant bonus for the flanker.

Mark Wilson of England celebrates on the final whistle (Getty Images)Mark Wilson of England celebrates on the ultimate whistle (Getty Pictures)

7. Tom Curry – 7/10

One landed to him behind the lineout on his personal 5 metre line within the 16th minute, and he took the chance to aim to bulldoze Handré Pollard to the cheers of the gang. A great efficiency ended sadly early as a result of an damage a minute into the second half. Made a variety of tackles in his brief time on the pitch – 10 in a single half.

eight. Mark Wilson – eight/10

Two inches shorter however 11lbs heavier than Tub’s Zach Mercer, Wilson was drafted in for his measurement and ball carrying means after an damage to Billy Vunipola and Nathan Hughes’ suspension. Early picks from the scrum have been about all of the ball carrying he did. The remaining was pure work in tackles, and disrupting South African possession like a breakdown machine. A mammoth effort from the Newcastle man earned him the person of the match accolade on TV.


16. Jamie George – 6/10

Got here on at 56 minutes for a sluggish Dylan Hartley and gained as many lineouts because the captain in that brief area of time. Didn’t put himself about within the unfastened as a lot as teammates.

17. Ben Moon – eight/10

Subbed on at half time for a debut that was all concerning the scrum. He made eight tackles within the 40 minutes he was on and England seemed extra strong within the scrum. A massively spectacular debut.

18. Harry Williams – 7/10

Gained an unlimited scrum within the 71st minute which earned a penalty and earned the primary real roar of the Twickenham crowd. Put himself about within the unfastened too. Good efficiency.

19. Charlie Ewels – 7/10

Got here on with three minutes to go and put his physique on the road instantly, making 7 tackles in that small stretch of time. Big for a really temporary window.

20. Zach Mercer – eight/10

Mercer, regardless of being earmarked as a expertise for the longer term and an ‘apprentice’ in earlier England squads, was not gambled on this check. Wilson from Newcastle was as an alternative drafted, probably as a consequence of his 11lb measurement benefit over Mercer towards a bodily Springbok pack. Debuted at openside for the injured Tom Curry a minute into the second-half, and England acquired to take pleasure in the perfect of each worlds. Began with a bang with some bulldozing and dynamic runs and solely improved from there as an asset in assault and defence.

21. Danny Care – 7/10

Care has been in robust type for Harlequins this season, and he received an enormous cheer approaching within the 64th minute. He sped up the tempo of the sport and England’s assault flowed extra freely with him on the base of the ruck – because it all the time does.

22. George Ford – 5/10

Ford was pushed to the bench for less than the third time within the final 24 internationals matches, since June 2016. The earlier two events have been the ultimate check of the South Africa tour in Cape City, and the ultimate match of the spring’s Six Nations towards Eire. Got here on within the 72nd minute for Ben Te’o. Appropriately held the move within the 74th minute to unlock the Springboks, however then bafflingly held onto it one other three yards to be tackled. Didn’t appear to be an improve on Farrell, it have to be stated, however he additionally didn’t have the ball as a lot as South Africa attacked late.

23. Chris Ashton – 6/10

The 31-year-old stepped into the fold to exchange the injured Manu Tuilagi on the bench after the squads had been introduced. Tuilagi is predicted to return for the New Zealand check. Got here on very late and made two passes.

South Africa

Henry Slade of England attempts to tackle Sibusiso Nkosi of South Africa as he scores his team's first try (Getty Images)Henry Slade of England makes an attempt to deal with Sibusiso Nkosi of South Africa as he scores his group’s first attempt (Getty Pictures)


15. Damian Willemse – 6/10

The gifted teenager performs a lot of his rugby at fly-half, and Rassie Erasmus has beforehand indicated he’s being groomed for the 10 jersey by means of 15. He appeared energetic with the ball and had fast ft. Seems to be like a nifty expertise.

14. Sbu Nkosi – 6/10

Completed his attempt properly, making certain he had the wheels to burn previous the overlaying Ben Te’o. Persistently gained excessive balls and in addition defended brilliantly. His deal with on Jack Nowell on the break within the second-half, stopped a really promising assault in his tracks. Three dangerous missed tackles displays poorly although. Was subbed off at 60 minutes.

13. Jesse Kriel – 5/10

Crunched Henry Slade man and ball as soon as, relying on the predictability of a miss move behind Te’o. Not a lot Slade might do with the sluggish move. The one deal with he made all match, and he didn’t do tons with the ball both. Little bit of an nameless outing right here.

12. Damian de Allende – 9/10

Likes to run by means of defenders on the top of well-distributed ball. Stored on drifting into extensive positions and trigger England’s new defence all types of issues. His break within the 77th minute particularly set the momentum for a promising assault and was a delight to behold. Distinctive efficiency.

11. Aphiwe Dyantyi – 6/10

Dyantyi’s robust tryscoring type on the worldwide stage was a speaking level earlier than the check, with six tries in 9 caps. The diminutive flyer on the wing set the tone defensively by coming in often to chop out broad passes with massive hits. Attacked cleverly too, placing in some threatening chips. Two missed tackles, matching together with his fellow winger, suggests his defence could possibly be higher.

10. Handré Pollard – 7/10

Broke via a missed deal with and unlocked the midfield with a stupendous bullet cross to de Allende. Tried to do the identical factor subsequent play and almost gifted Henry Slade. A combined recreation at occasions and also you’d be proper to ask why he wasn’t demanding extra makes an attempt at objective from England’s 11 penalties.

9. Ivan van Zyl – 9/10

The younger scrum-half was drafted in after Sale Sharks refused to launch World Participant of the Yr nominee Faf de Klerk. Enjoying inside his clubmate, the 23-year-old had a chance to stake a declare for the shirt. From the start he organised his forwards properly and was rewarded with floor and a platform. Field kicked properly too. Stored sniping for the road, a bit predictably. His deft kick on the stroke of half-time to take advantage of Elliot Daly’s dashing up, confirmed a relaxed temperament for a person incomes his fourth cap. A superb day on the workplace ended on the 74th minute.

South Africa's centre Damian de Allende evades a tackle from England's centre Henry Slade (AFP/Getty Images)South Africa’s centre Damian de Allende evades a deal with from England’s centre Henry Slade (AFP/Getty Photographs)


1. Steven Kitshoff – 5/10

Scrummaged nicely early however fell away as the sport went on. Made a number of carries however was not at his handiest and imposing and didn’t contribute a lot to defence. Substituted off at 64 minutes.

2. Malcolm Marx – three/10

Early knock on with no strain. Overthrew his lineout twice within the first half on the 5 metre line – there’s arguably 14 factors in these dangerous errors. Did it once more in addition. Rassie should have been fuming. Made lots of runs, but in addition missed a deal with. Got here off with 5 minutes to go, it arguably ought to have been earlier.

three. Frans Malherbe – 5/10

Did little or no ball carrying in any respect, and his scrummaging means waned as the sport went on. Missed a deal with, and conceded a turnover. Not a fantastic day. Substituted off at 64 minutes.

four. Eben Etzebeth – 5/10

His recreation ended early as a result of an damage within the 41st minute, however he hadn’t been that influential.

5. Pieter-Steph du Toit – eight/10

Monumental, bludgeoning efficiency from the second row. 13 tackles and an entire lot of rucks hit and floor gained. Made probably the most runs in his aspect and may take coronary heart in an impressive recreation.

6. Siya Kolisi – four/10

Monumental in defence early, with a few robust hits early on. Knocked on off a driving maul 5 metres out and his recreation subsided after. Conceded two turnovers, missed two tackles and solely made six. Substituted off at 64 minutes.

7. Duane Vermeulen – 5/10

His mood flared within the second half, almost inflicting a punchup till he was informed by the referee he had the penalty. Didn’t do tonnes in defence however made numerous carries – 11 in complete. Must do extra of the ugly stuff.

eight. Warren Whiteley – 7/10

Robust efficiency from the cellular quantity eight, each in assault and defence. Wrapped up the ball nicely incessantly too and was a complete menace to English attackers.


16. Bongi Mbonambi – four/10

Got here on with 15 minutes to go. Misplaced a scrum and didn’t do a lot within the unfastened. Poor cameo.

17. Thomas du Toit – 6/10

Got here on with not a lot time to go in any respect. Made an excellent deal with.

18. Wilco Louw – 6/10

Within the brief time he was on the sector he carried and tackled as a lot as he bodily might in a interval the Springboks have been making an attempt to claw again the match.

19. RG Snyman – 5/10

On for Eben Eztebeth barely sooner than he may need anticipated – a minute into the second-half because of an damage. Was put to work instantly with exhausting tackles an massive clearouts, however he made some defensive errors that have to be thought-about.

20. Lood de Jager – four/10

Got here on within the 65 minute to offer some ballast, however as an alternative misplaced the ball twice.

21. Embrose Papier – 7/10

Got here on within the 74th for the distinctive Van Zyl. Tried to up the tempo of assault and drive the ‘boks house. Almost succeeded.

Comply with us on Fb: @iPaperSport

22. Elton Jantjies – 6/10

Got here on for Pollard with 4 minutes to go. Clearly distributes properly and is aware of learn how to orchestrate an assault.

23. André Esterhuizen – four/10

Topic of Farrell’s disputed deal with on the whistle after approaching for Nkosi at 60 minutes. Didn’t get as a lot area or time on the ball as he would have favored and appeared fairly ineffective. No defenders crushed.